Brazilian poultry exporters are defending their growing presence in South Africa, rejecting allegations that shipments are undermining local producers and arguing that imported chicken products help close supply gaps, support food manufacturers and maintain access to affordable protein when domestic production comes under pressure.
The debate is highlighting a difficult balancing act for South Africa’s poultry industry: protecting local farmers and encouraging domestic investment while ensuring that consumers and food manufacturers have reliable supplies of poultry products at competitive prices.
At the centre of the dispute is the Brazilian Association of Animal Protein (ABPA), which says Brazilian poultry should not automatically be considered a threat to South African producers because the two countries do not always supply the same products or serve identical market segments.
ABPA President Ricardo Santin said Brazil supplies South Africa with products that are either unavailable or produced in insufficient quantities domestically. One of the key products is mechanically deboned meat, commonly known as MDM, which is widely used as an ingredient in processed meat products.
South Africa remains an important Brazilian market
South Africa has become a significant destination for Brazilian poultry. In 2025, Brazil exported approximately 336,022 tonnes of chicken meat to South Africa, making the country Brazil’s fourth-largest chicken export market.
South Africa accounted for about 6.5 percent of Brazil’s total chicken exports during the year.
The figures put the South African market behind the United Arab Emirates, which received about 479,944 tonnes, Japan with 402,901 tonnes and Saudi Arabia with 397,225 tonnes.
The scale of Brazil’s exports reflects the country’s position as one of the world’s major poultry-producing and exporting nations. Its industry has developed an extensive production and processing system capable of supplying different categories of chicken products to markets around the world.
For Brazilian exporters, South Africa represents an important destination because of its large consumer market and established food-processing sector.
Why mechanically deboned meat matters
ABPA Executive Manager for Markets Estevao Carvalho said the composition of Brazilian poultry imports needs to be considered when assessing their impact on local farmers.
A substantial share of the trade involves MDM, which is produced by mechanically recovering meat remaining on poultry bones after higher-value portions have been removed.
The resulting product is commonly used in processed foods because it is an economical source of poultry protein. It can be incorporated into products such as sausages, viennas, polony and other processed meat products, as well as some pet-food formulations.
Carvalho argues that South Africa does not produce enough MDM to satisfy industrial demand, making imports necessary for manufacturers that depend on the ingredient.
This distinction is important because competition between imported MDM and locally produced whole birds or chicken portions is not necessarily direct. The imported product can instead provide an ingredient for food manufacturers that require large and consistent supplies.
Imports face significant tariffs
Brazilian exporters also point to the import duties imposed on their products as evidence that the trade is already subject to significant protection.
According to ABPA, Brazilian poultry entering South Africa faces tariffs of 42 percent on deboned chicken products, 62 percent on bone-in chicken and 82 percent on whole chickens.
Such duties increase the landed cost of imported poultry and are intended to provide some protection to domestic producers.
However, the continued flow of Brazilian poultry into the market shows that demand for imports remains strong despite these trade barriers.
For importers and food manufacturers, the argument is that access to international supplies is necessary when local production cannot provide every product category in sufficient volume or at competitive prices.
Importers say food security must also be considered
Paul Matthew, chief executive of South Africa’s Association of Meat Importers and Exporters, said the country needs to look beyond import restrictions and focus on improving the competitiveness of its own poultry industry.
He pointed to Brazil’s integrated poultry model as an example of how the industry can build efficiency through closer links between feed production, breeding, farming, processing and marketing.
Brazil’s large-scale integrated system allows companies to coordinate different stages of production and benefit from economies of scale. Matthew argued that South Africa could strengthen its own poultry sector by developing similar efficiencies.
South Africa’s poultry master plan, introduced in 2019, identified export development as one of the industry’s objectives. However, domestic producers have yet to establish the country as a major international poultry exporter.This highlights a significant gap between South Africa’s ambitions and its current position in global poultry trade.
Disease threats complicate domestic production
The import debate is also being shaped by the vulnerability of domestic meat production to animal diseases.Georg Southey, general manager of Merlog Foods, said imports provide an important source of supply when diseases disrupt local production.
South Africa’s livestock and poultry industries have faced threats from diseases including highly pathogenic avian influenza, foot-and-mouth disease and African swine fever.
Disease outbreaks can reduce livestock numbers, interrupt production schedules, increase costs and restrict the movement or marketing of animals and animal products.For poultry processors and food manufacturers, these disruptions can make alternative sources of supply important for maintaining production.
Southey estimated that imported meat represents about 10 percent of South Africa’s overall meat consumption, illustrating the role international trade plays in the country’s broader food system.
Brazilian MDM supports processed-food production
The importance of imports is particularly visible in South Africa’s processed-food sector.Southey said Brazilian MDM is an important ingredient for products such as viennas and polony, which are widely consumed and often positioned as relatively affordable protein products.
He estimated that products made using imported MDM contribute to more than 100 million meals each week.
This means the debate over poultry imports is not limited to farmers and traders. It also affects food manufacturers, retailers and consumers who depend on processed meat products.
Restricting imports without ensuring alternative domestic supplies could therefore create challenges for manufacturers and potentially increase costs along the food chain.
Local producers face their own cost pressures
South African poultry farmers, meanwhile, argue that competition from imported products can make it harder for domestic producers to recover their production costs and invest in expansion.The industry has faced pressures from feed prices, electricity costs, infrastructure constraints, animal disease outbreaks and other operating expenses.
Feed is particularly important because maize and soybean-based ingredients represent major components of poultry diets. Changes in grain prices can therefore quickly affect the cost of producing chicken.Local producers must also invest heavily in biosecurity, housing, energy, water, labour, veterinary services and processing infrastructure.
These expenses can make it difficult for smaller and less integrated producers to compete with highly efficient international suppliers.
Protection versus competitiveness
The dispute over Brazilian poultry imports raises a fundamental question for South Africa: should the country focus primarily on restricting imports, or should it use competition as an incentive to make domestic production more efficient?
Industry stakeholders increasingly recognise that long-term competitiveness cannot depend on tariffs alone.South Africa would need stronger investment across the poultry value chain, including efficient feed production, improved genetics, modern housing systems, better disease surveillance, reliable electricity and water supplies, efficient processing facilities and stronger logistics.
The country would also need to develop more value-added poultry products capable of competing in regional and international markets.
Brazil’s experience demonstrates the potential benefits of integration. Its poultry industry has built a strong export-oriented model capable of serving different markets with fresh, frozen and processed products.
Africa’s growing poultry demand creates opportunities
The dispute also comes as demand for poultry continues to rise across Africa.Population growth, urbanisation and increasing demand for affordable animal protein are expanding poultry markets across the continent. Countries that can produce chicken efficiently and maintain strong disease-control systems are likely to have opportunities both in domestic markets and regional trade.
For South Africa, improving domestic competitiveness could therefore provide a double benefit: reducing vulnerability to imports while creating opportunities to export poultry products to neighbouring countries.Brazilian suppliers, however, are already well established in international markets and have developed extensive logistics and customer networks.
A strategic decision for South Africa
The current disagreement is ultimately about more than whether Brazilian poultry constitutes dumping. It reflects competing priorities within South Africa’s food system.
Local farmers need an environment that allows them to earn sustainable returns and invest in production. Food manufacturers require reliable supplies of suitable raw materials. Importers want access to competitive international products, while consumers need affordable sources of protein.
Finding the right balance will require policies that protect the strategic interests of domestic agriculture without creating shortages or excessive food-price increases.
For South Africa’s poultry industry, the challenge now is to turn protection into competitiveness. If local producers can overcome high production costs, strengthen integration, improve disease resilience and invest in modern technology, the country could move beyond defending its domestic market and begin building a stronger export-oriented poultry industry. Until then, Brazilian imports are likely to remain an important part of the country’s food supply, particularly where domestic production cannot consistently meet demand.





